Stock Market Gyrations: Do They Change Valuations?

Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links, which generate income for this free website at no cost to you. This article is written for entertainment purposes only and should not be construed as financial or any other type of professional advice.

My oldest son and I have been working together to develop valuations of potential stock picks. I designed a spreadsheet to estimate the per-share value of stocks, drawing on information I discussed in my article on stock analysis. The spreadsheet, combined with expert resources, has helped me to make good investment decisions.

After some discussion about the rationale for my spreadsheet design and a few tips on finding the financial data, my son researched several stocks and determined their valuations. We discussed the results, noting securities that were undervalued (that is, their current share price was below its true value) and many that were overvalued (they had share prices above the value).

Then he went back for his senior year in college, a few weeks passed, and the market fell dramatically.

Next, I got an excited phone call and my investment-minded son asked me if a market decline meant an (automatic) change in stock valuations.

This question took me aback. The whole point of the stock-analysis exercise was to determine the intrinsic value of the shares of certain stocks. What the market was doing on a particular day had nothing to do with true value, as I’ve learned from reading of The Intelligent Investor, which covers value investing and market gyrations. I felt frustrated that I hadn’t taught him this basic principle.

But then I realized that in a world of people going crazy, his question was a reasonable one to ask.

To the question “does a market decline change stock valuations?,” the simple answer is “no.”

Certainly, there could be exceptions. A market decline that reflects slower than expected economic growth could change valuations that are dependent on growth.

But, in general, if I can calculate the intrinsic value of a stock accurately (that is determine the exact share price the stock is worth), the underlying value doesn’t change just because its price fluctuates.

An example might be helpful. Let’s say that I determine the value of Stock ABC to be $50. At that time, the shares sell for $55, so I could say that the stock is overvalued. The company continues to thrive and generate income, income growth, and cash flow as expected for the next few months. But then the market (comprised of 500+ individual stocks) declines and the share price of Stock ABC falls to $40.

Are the shares still worth $50?

The simple answer is “yes.” The value doesn’t change just because the market has a bad day. Now, and not to make things complicated, when (if ever) the shares will bounce back to $50 or even $55 is unknowable. But generally, their inherent worth remains.

What does change with market fluctuations — and price fluctuations of an individual stock — is the safety margin associated with the stock purchase. As Benjamin Graham wrote in The Intelligent Investor, “The margin of safety is always dependent on the price paid. It will be large at one price, small at some higher price, and nonexistent at some still higher price.”

Using our Stock ABC as an example, its safety margin could be considered large at a price of $25; small at a price of $40; and nonexistent at $55. When the stock price of a fundamentally sound business goes down, the safety margin for the stock as an investment increases. Not only is a safer investment more attractive than a riskier one, there is greater opportunity for investment growth when I buy at lower prices.

So, stock valuations don’t change even when the stock market does.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.